Ram Karki’s ridiculous claims
Sujit Mainali / November 7, 2017
Leader of the CPN (Maoist Center) and former communications minister Surendra Kumar Karki (better known as Ram Karki) made several claims during an interview aired on Sagarmatha TV on November 5. South Asia Check has examined whether the following two claims are fact-based or not:
First Claim: Jhapa district’s parliamentary constituency number 1 alone has more languages than any other zone or province of Nepal.
According to ‘Nepali Population and Housing Census, 2011’, 72 languages are spoken in Jhapa district. Even if we assume that all these languages are spoken in the district’s constituency number 1, then still it would be wrong to say the constituency has more languages than any other district or zone. According to the census report, Jhapa’s neighboring district Morang also has 72 languages and 80 languages are spoken in Kathmandu district.
Therefore, Karki’s claim is wrong.
Second Claim: If we grow rice efficiently in 2,000 bigha of land, then it will be enough to meet the rice requirement of half of the population of Nepal.
According to the Ministry of Agriculture Development, 2,374,389 metric tons of rice was produced in the fiscal year 2015/16. This covered 43.75 percent of the total requirement of food in Nepal that year (Statistical Information on Nepalese Agriculture, Pg 131-33, 2015/16, Ministry of Agriculture Development).
Assuming that the total rice produced in Nepal this year was enough to meet the rice requirement of the country, we can say that 11,87194.5 metric tons of rice was needed to meet the rice requirement of country’s half of the population in that year.
US is among the countries with highest rice productivity. In 2015, US produced 8.37 metric tons of rice per hectare.
Even if we are able to boost our rice productivity to match that of the US through use of advanced agricultural technologies and better seeds, we can produce 11,337.41 metric tons rice from 2000 bigha [1354.53 hectares] of land. And this amount will still fall short of 1,175,857.09 metric tons to meet the rice requirement of half of the population of Nepal.
If, through some sheer miracle, we succeeded in boosting our rice productivity by 100 times than that of the US, we could produce 1,133,741.61 metric tons of rice. But we would still require another 53,452.89 metric tons to fulfill rice requirement of half of the population of the country. Therefore, Karki’s claim is preposterous.
This material is copyrighted but may be used for any purpose by giving due credit to southasiacheck.org.
- In Public Interest There was a time when rice was Nepal’s major export item
- Fact Check Ex-UML chief exaggerates party’s 1997 poll performance
- Fact Check Thapa makes chronological mistake about Dabur, Unilever
- Media How justified is the use of anonymous sources?
- In Public Interest Communities that have been able to make it to parliament without reservation
- Fact Check Agricultural land shrinking in tarai due to flooding
In Public InterestThere was a time when rice was Nepal’s major export item Several news reports and articles published in Gorkhapatra between 1974 and 1975 said the agricultur... Read More
- Communities that have been able to make it to parliament without reservation
- Birth date mismatch problem isn’t going away soon
- Few women elected to parliament under FPTP
- Six women elected to parliament under FPTP system
- Tall poll promises!