In the Rana-era, both hill and tarai people needed passport to visit Kathmandu
Sujit Mainali / December 15, 2016
Upendra Yadav, the chairman of the Federal Socialist Forum, Nepal during an interview with the Himalaya TV programme ‘Yaksha Prashna‘ aired on December 2 made the following assertions. South Asia Check has examined whether his assertions are fact-based or not.
First Assertion: [We had not demanded two provinces in the tarai], they raised this issue. We had demanded one province [for the entire tarai]…The demand of the first Madhes uprising was the creation of one Madhes province. The agreement reached with Girija Prasad was for the formation of one Madhes province for the tarai.
After the first Madhes uprising, the government led by Girija Prasad Koirala signed an agreement with the then Madhesi People’s Rights Forum Nepal on September 9, 2007 wherein it was mentioned that federalism will be introduced in Nepal. The agreement has nowhere mentioned about forming one Madhes province for the entire tarai.
Similarly, after the second Madhes uprising, Girija Prasad Koirala-led government signed an agreement with three leading Madhesi parties on February 28, 2008. In that agreement, it was mentioned that “by accepting the Madhesi people’s wish for an autonomous Madhes…Nepal shall become a federal democratic republic.”
In both the agreements, there is no mention of creating one single Madhes province for the tarai.
Therefore, Chairman Yadav is wrong in saying that the agreement reached with Girija Prasad Koirala was for the formation of one province for the entire tarai.
Second Assertion: There was a time when one needed passport and visa to come to Kathmandu from Birgunj. [Madhesis were] treated like foreigners.
Frederich H Gaige, an author who has written a book on tarai, too has mentioned that except on the occasion of Shiva Ratri festival, the residents of the tarai had to obtain passport in Birgunj before visiting Kathmandu. (For detail, read Gaige’s book “Regionalism an National Unity in Nepal” published by Himal Books and translated by Mohan Mainali in Nepali language)
The assertion of Yadav is similar to the information given in the book. Therefore, his assertion is correct.
But the statements of both Yadav and Gaige gives the impression that passport was needed only to the people of the tarai while visiting Kathmandu, which is wrong.
“Notes from the translator” section in the translated version of Gaige’s book states, “Both Madhesi and Pahadi who descended [to the tarai] from the Kathmandu Valley and who came to the Kathmandu Valley from the tarai had to obtain passport. Sardaar Bhim Bahadur Pandey in his book “Nepal of that time (Tyas Bakhat ko Nepal)-Part 1, on page number 25, has said, “During those days, every Nepali who used the route of Chisapani Gadhi to visit the tarai and come to Kathmandu had to obtain a passport—passport to leave the Kathmandu Valley had to be obtained from Sadar Thana in Kathmandu and the passport needed to enter the Valley had to be obtained from the head of the Gadhi.”
Even the people from Kathmandu had to obtain a passport if they wished to visit other parts of Nepal through Chisapani Gadhi. A founding leader of the Nepali Congress, Ganesh Man Singh, who was from the Newar community of the Kathmandu Valley, has mentioned in his memoir that during the Rana period, he had once tried to flee Kathmandu in the guise of a hill-Brahmin. While crossing the Chisapani Gadhi, he showed a passport issued in his name to the staffers of the Gadhi. “When the staffers of the Gadhi asked me to produce my passport, I flipped open the Chandi [a Hindu scripture] book and showed them the passport which I had kept inside. They thought I was a pious Brahmin and did not enquire further,” he has said in a memoir. (Ganesh Man Singh, Pages of my Life, Part 1, Presenter: Mathwar Singh)
Third Assertion: When the First Muluki Ain was enacted, Junga Bahadur [introduced a system] in which people from lower castes were regarded as Masine Jaat, they could be killed [without fear of penalty], but the people from higher castes [were exempted from the provision].
During the tenure of Junga Bahadur Rana, first Muluki Ain (Civil Code) 1910 was enacted. This Civil Code legalized the discrimination based on Hindu caste system. The Code had categorized Nepali people under the following five groups:
- Tagadhari (Those wearing the sacred thread called Janai across their torso)
- Namasine Matuwali (Unenslavable liquor drinkers)
- Masine Matuwali (Enslavable liquor drinkers)
- Pani Nachalne Chhoi Chhito Halnu Naparne (Impure but touchable)
- Pani Nachalne Chhoi Chhito Halnu Parne (Impure and untouchable, upon touching whom one needed to purify themselves by sprinkling gold-dipped water)
Under this system, people from the so-called lowest caste group were placed under Pani Nachalne Chhoi Chhito Halnu Parne group.
The word “masinya” used in the Civil Code meant “those who can be enslaved”. (For details, read Andras Hofer’s “The Caste Hierarchy and the State in Nepal, A study of the Muluki Ain of 1856” published by Himal Books)
Yadav in his interview has claimed that the word masinya means “those who could be killed”.
Therefore, this assertion is also wrong.
This material is copyrighted but may be used for any purpose by giving due credit to southasiacheck.org.
- Fact Check Some pictures circulating as this week’s Melamchi flooding scenes are old
- Fact Check Video clips falsely suggest Covid-19 vaccine makes human body magnetic
- Fact Check Prime minister’s press advisor wrongly claims Chure hills lie only in Nepal
- Fact Check Birtamod mayor’s misleading remedies for Covid-19 and false claims fact-checked
- Fact Check Old man in viral social media posts is a US WWII veteran, not a Covid-recovered Italian
- Fact Check Nepal village photo used in the context of Indian cricket misleads many
In Public InterestRead this before opting for alternative remedies for Covid-19 The effects of reckless consumption of herbs may not be seen immediately, but it can cause harm in t... Read More
- Scientists worldwide in desperate search for COVID-19 drug
- Six things to know for cannabis legalization in Nepal
- Women ministers in Nepal
- Brace yourself for toxic winter air
- Nepal has no technology to test alleged use of oxytocin in fruits and vegetables