Approval of unaffected provinces is not needed for altering provincial boundaries
Sujit Mainali / May 9, 2017
Nepali Congress central committee member Dr Shekhar Koirala in an article titled “Formula for solution: Consensus government” published in Naya Patrika daily on April 30, said the following:
“Of course, a new province can be carved out of Province 5. But how reasonable would it be to seek permission from Province 1 for carving a new province out of Province 5?”
South Asia Check has examined whether the permission of Province 1 is required to alter the boundary of Province 5 or not.
For this, we studied the provisions of the Constitution of Nepal-2072 regarding making changes to the provincial boundaries.
Clause 5 and 7 of Article 274 of the constitution state that the amendment bill meant for altering the boundary of a province(s) should be endorsed by simple majority of the provincial assemblies concerned.
Agitating Madhes-based parties are demanding parliamentary endorsement of the provisions on altering the provincial boundaries mentioned in the first amendment bill brought by the incumbent Pushpa Kamal Dahal-led government.
Dr Koirala has mentioned the same amendment bill [which has already been withdrawn by the government] in his article.
If the provincial boundaries are altered as per the first amendment bill, then the boundaries of Province 4, Province 5 and Province 6 will change.
If the provincial assemblies of two out of the three provinces concerned accept the bill through simple majority, the federal parliament can endorse the bill through its two-thirds majority.
None of the provisions of the constitution makes it mandatory to seek the permission of Province 1 to alter the boundaries of Province 5.
Therefore, Dr Koirala’s statement is wrong.
This material is copyrighted but may be used for any purpose by giving due credit to southasiacheck.org.
In Public InterestThis is how falsehood spreads On April 27, 2017 Indian news website news18.com published a piece about Nepal’s upcoming local el... Read More
- Looking back at reconstruction
- Women’s representation will increase after elections
- Is provincial consent mandatory in US and India for altering provincial boundaries?
- The Uprooted
- Labor permit will be beneficial for India-bound Nepali workers